Today's Washington Post included an interesting article on "
moms at war" -- the tension between stay-at-home moms and working moms. Written by Leslie Morgan Steiner, it's part of an anthology on the subject that Ms. Steiner edited. Parts of the article really resonated with me, such as this passage:
I went back to my job the Tuesday after Memorial Day, Max's 3-month birthday. I was amazed to be paying another woman to do what I craved most in the world, to stay home with my little bird. While I drove out of the driveway, dressed in a black coatdress and full makeup for the first time in weeks, my heart lay beating on the changing table.
I can remember my first day back at work after the squeaker's birth quite vividly. My hands felt so empty all day long. At first, I felt lost. But after a few days, I felt empowered -- hours at a time, with two hands and no one crying at me! I could read my e-mail in peace. I could write coherent sentences! I could make phone calls! And then I felt guilty for enjoying having a bit of my pre-baby self -- my "professional" self -- back, when my baby was left without his mama.
The motherhood/career dilemma has to be among the most difficult issues facing women of my generation, and there's certainly an irony to that -- after all, previous generations of women trailblazed difficult terrain so that their daughters and granddaughters could have choices, and yet those very choices are the core of a working mother's aching heart. As a working mom, I sometimes feel that the truly important parts of my life end up squeezed into its margins, when they should be the main focus. I don't feel driven by career ambition -- I don't find much personal fulfillment in work, and I'm not a person who needs to be busy all the time to be happy -- but somehow working fits with my sense of self-identity. As a little girl, I wanted to be something: a doctor, a teacher, an archeologist. I also wanted to be a mother, but that never struck me as incompatible with other goals. It really never occurred to me that there might be a period of time where I would just want to be a mother. And even now, while motherhood seems to be my most important and valuable role, I cannot imagine giving myself wholly to it for the long term. And yet I can't figure out how to strike the balance that I want -- motherhood now, something else later, in a few years when the squeaker doesn't need me quite so much. I feel that any choice I make involves some loss.
In any case, I don't really think moms are at war with each other. Our criticisms of our fellow moms reflect our own fears and insecurities. Both working moms and stay at home moms are not always honest with ourselves. Working moms give up precious time with a child who most wants -- and needs -- his or her mom. We do it because we believe it's worth it not just for ourselves, but for our little ones. We believe our children benefit from the extra income, and from seeing their mom in another role. But our choice means that sometimes our little ones look for a mom who is not there. That the shoulder that comforts our child is not ours, but a day care provider paid to care for our child. That our children's own routines are forced to conform to the requirements of our work days, and of our day care providers. And we must recognize that we have the luxury of working because other people are willing to care for our children.
Stay at home moms sacrifice something, too. They give up financial independence and a kind of self-focus that can be important to personal growth. And they rely on the financial support of a community to which they do not contribute every time they ride a public bus or check out a library book. They benefit from the work that others do when they breathe clean air or drink clean water, when they drive on paved roads or use safe consumer products. Certainly stay at home moms make their own significant contribution to society (by raising its youngest members), but their ability to do so -- while enjoying the benefits of living in that society -- means that they are in part financially supported by moms who work outside the home.
No woman is an island. And all mothers face choices that involve balancing cost and benefit. We must keep our interdependence -- and our shared knowledge that motherhood represents a unique intersection of emotions and identities -- in mind before we criticize one another.