A Pirate's Life for Smee
We’ve gotten into this bad habit of watching movies in the evening. Once it’s dark, we settle on our couch to snuggle in front of some kid-friendly film. I keep thinking that once it’s warm out, we’ll stop. We’ll see, I guess.
In any case, last night’s movie was Disney’s Peter Pan. I hadn’t seen the film in a long time and I had forgotten how painful parts of it really are. At first, I was struck by its misogyny – the female characters are either saintly mothers or sexy hotheads who are so insanely jealous of any other woman’s attention to Peter that they resort to betrayal and physical aggression. But then it occurred to me that the male characters don’t really fare any better – Mr. Darling is a doddering fool, the lost boys are uncouth animals in need of the civilizing touch of a woman, and Peter himself is a portrait in immature self-indulgence. And yes, I know that’s the point – never having to grow up, resisting responsibility, blah blah blah, but really, his faults are less about being a little boy and more about being a plain old cad. And then there’s the “Injuns”…ugh.
In any case, I was kind of relieved when the squeaker grew bored and decided to play with his Playmobil pirate ship instead. I guess I’ll have to decide if he can watch it again. Most of the movies we choose are not so full of overt and outdated stereotypes. The squeaker likes Mulan (which sometimes seems to play into stereotypes in its efforts to skew them, but is a good film nonetheless) and Lilo & Stitch. We don’t have Sleeping Beauty or Snow White, and I think they’d be painful to watch with him.
Still, watching the film created the opportunity for a most amusing exchange with the squeaker. I usually explain the movie when we are watching it for the first time; I tell him about the plot and point out the characters. So when Captain Hook and the bumbling Smee appeared, I said, “That’s the pirate Captain Hook and that’s Smee, his helper.”
The squeaker watched for a while, and then gave me a perplexed look. When Smee appeared again, he said, “Mama, that’s you?”
“What? That’s Smee.”
“It’s you?”
“What are you talking about? I didn’t say it was me. I said it was Smee.”
And then I realized how it sounded to him.
In any case, last night’s movie was Disney’s Peter Pan. I hadn’t seen the film in a long time and I had forgotten how painful parts of it really are. At first, I was struck by its misogyny – the female characters are either saintly mothers or sexy hotheads who are so insanely jealous of any other woman’s attention to Peter that they resort to betrayal and physical aggression. But then it occurred to me that the male characters don’t really fare any better – Mr. Darling is a doddering fool, the lost boys are uncouth animals in need of the civilizing touch of a woman, and Peter himself is a portrait in immature self-indulgence. And yes, I know that’s the point – never having to grow up, resisting responsibility, blah blah blah, but really, his faults are less about being a little boy and more about being a plain old cad. And then there’s the “Injuns”…ugh.
In any case, I was kind of relieved when the squeaker grew bored and decided to play with his Playmobil pirate ship instead. I guess I’ll have to decide if he can watch it again. Most of the movies we choose are not so full of overt and outdated stereotypes. The squeaker likes Mulan (which sometimes seems to play into stereotypes in its efforts to skew them, but is a good film nonetheless) and Lilo & Stitch. We don’t have Sleeping Beauty or Snow White, and I think they’d be painful to watch with him.
Still, watching the film created the opportunity for a most amusing exchange with the squeaker. I usually explain the movie when we are watching it for the first time; I tell him about the plot and point out the characters. So when Captain Hook and the bumbling Smee appeared, I said, “That’s the pirate Captain Hook and that’s Smee, his helper.”
The squeaker watched for a while, and then gave me a perplexed look. When Smee appeared again, he said, “Mama, that’s you?”
“What? That’s Smee.”
“It’s you?”
“What are you talking about? I didn’t say it was me. I said it was Smee.”
And then I realized how it sounded to him.
